More notably, Burchstead set up two large whale bones in the form of a “gothic arch” as his front gate. Alonzo Lewis, followed by other authors, said that visitors to Lynn embarrassed to have people know they were consulting Pitcher would instead ask for directions to “the bones of the great whale.”
There’s one problem with those directions, however. According to a genealogy published in the Massachusetts Magazine in 1910, Dr. Henry Burchstead died in 1755, five years before Moll Pitcher married and decades before Lewis and those other chroniclers lived. [CORRECTION: The Dr. Burchsted who died in 1755 was succeeded by his son, another Dr. Henry Burchsted, who lived to 1807. The younger man set up the whalebone gate.] James R. Newhall’s 1897 expansion of Lewis’s history of Lynn said other doctors took over that house: Dr. Peter G. Robbins in 1805 and Dr. Richard Hazeltine in 1817. But it’s not clear who lived there from 1755 to 1805, covering the bulk of Moll Pitcher’s career. In any case, people looked for the whale bones.
Lewis described “the humble dwelling of Molly Pitcher, which stood on what was then a lonely road, near the foot of High Rock.” A less flattering, secondhand description of Pitcher published in the 12 July 1879 Boston Traveller and reprinted in the 15 July New York Times said the house was
a black two-story hovel, which stood in a large field, familiarly called in those days the Pitcher field. There was a well-beaten pathway running from the old rickety gate up to the single door. Before the door, was placed an irregular block of stone, and even that, to the superstitious, had its terrors. . . .In the March 1899 Essex Antiquarian, Sidney Perley published a picture of the Pitcher house “as it formerly appeared.” It looks like it had one story and an attic, four windows in front, and a small extension on the left side. That picture shows a standard Georgian center door while the 1879 article stated the “single door…stood to the extreme left of the house and opened into a small entry-way, which, in turn, opened into a rather larger room, where Moll received her visitors. There were two small rooms adjoining this large one, where were used for various purposes.” Those two reports seem incompatible.
The field where the cottage stood has been filled with nice dwellings, and there is not a sign left of the mysterious dwelling-place…except the remodeled hovel which stands in the rear. It has been materially changed and would scarcely be recognized.
Perley included three other relics of Mary Pitcher: her signature from some 1770 document, a black bonnet she was known to wear, and a table.
TOMORROW: The exposé.
I assume you've contacted the Essex Museum?!
ReplyDeleteIf the PEM has it, they probably keep it as far from display as possible- their interpretive method in respect to "witchy" artifacts is to keep them out of the public conciousness, lest visitors show up wanting to actually see them. The museum's administrators have stated in the past that the "witch tourism" phenomenon (otherwise known as the modern backbone of Salem's economy) is not for them, and that they will play no part in interpreting that history- the need for accurate interpretation apparently notwithstanding.
ReplyDeleteI checked the P.E.M.’s online catalogue for items connected to the Pitcher family but didn’t contact the museum.
ReplyDeleteMy remark about “Salem’s witch tourism season” was facetious since these days every season in Salem is about witch tourism, and the region’s rich history of other events has been well overshadowed.
Moll Pitcher shows how the area moved in a century from the witch hysteria to a community accepting an older woman telling fortunes for a living. Interesting history, but perhaps not what tourists want.
Dr. Burchstead who had the whale bones for a gateway was my ancestor. Look up (google) the story of how he got those whale bones
ReplyDelete. Wow! MOST interesting
Dr. Henry Burchstead was my 6th great grandfather. He hitched up his horse to a rocking chair, then rode all the way into the belly of a beached (deceased) 70 ft. whale. The
ReplyDeleteI discussed Dr. Burchsted and the whale in this post. The early source I quoted uses the word “chair” not to mean a common piece of of household furniture but a small cart. The word had many meanings according to Webster’s 1828 dictionary, and the small wheeled cart makes the most sense in this context.
ReplyDelete