“A serious subversion of our commitment to history”
Mike McIntire and Eli Murray wrote:
Justice Antonin Scalia, writing for the majority in the 2008 case, District of Columbia v. Heller, attributed the “dangerous and unusual” language to Sir William Blackstone, an 18th-century English jurist whose writings became the basis for much of American law.This offers another example of a question I discussed in 2012 and again in 2022: How do we treat Supreme Court rulings founded in historical claims that are demonstrably wrong?
But in his seminal 1769 treatise, “Commentaries on the Laws of England,” Blackstone referred to weapons that were “dangerous or unusual,” suggesting that a gun did not need to be both in order to be restricted. . . .
In another gun-related opinion in 2016, just a month after Justice Scalia died, Justice Samuel Alito amplified and sharpened the message. He placed a particular emphasis on the word “and.” Justice Alito asserted that Heller established “a conjunctive test: A weapon may not be banned unless it is both dangerous and unusual.” . . .
The consequences of Justice Scalia’s use of “and” rather than “or” have been profound. Since all guns are dangerous, courts have had to focus instead on determining whether a type of firearm is unusual, often parsing marketing data and consumer surveys to gauge a weapon’s popularity.
Other judges have noted Scalia’s error. The article states:
Last year, a federal appeals court upheld Connecticut’s assault-weapons ban, saying it was in keeping with a tradition of restricting “unusually dangerous” weapons and explicitly rejecting the “dangerous and unusual” test that arose from Heller.That case, and another from Illinois, are up for argument at the Supreme Court in December.
“It would seem a serious subversion of our commitment to history to enshrine a conjunctive test based on the Heller opinion’s possible misquote of Blackstone,” the appeals court said.
(The photo above shows Justice Scalia in eighteenth-century costume, not for channeling what Blackstone should have said but to appear as an extra in an opera.)



.jpeg)







.jpg)