Tracking Back Sources on the Break between Hancock and Adams
Wells was a descendant, and his book reflects the family’s idealized portrait of the man, but it’s also our source for a lot of personal information, such as the name of Adams’s dog.
In discussing the breakdown of the Hancock-Adams alliance in 1776 at volume 2, pages 383–4, Wells offered three citations.
The first came from the Rev. William Gordon’s History of the Rise, Progress, and Establishment, of the Independence of the United States of America. As I’ve said before, Adams was obviously one of Gordon’s main sources. He presents Adams’s side of the dispute. Furthermore, Gordon wrote in the mid-1780s when the split between Hancock and Adams was at its widest, and that no doubt colored his portrayal. I wanted contemporaneous sources on how the rift began.
Wells’s second source was a story “industriously circulated with exaggerations by the Tories, one of whom gravely published ‘intelligence of great credibility,’ which had lately arrived in Massachusetts from Philadelphia.” Wells’s described that article as saying, “Adams had made a motion in Congress for the expulsion of Hancock for holding principles incompatible with independency.” His footnote cited: “‘Caesar,’ in the Middlesex Gazette, Dec. 26.”
There was, however, no American newspaper called the Middlesex Gazette in 1776. (One would be founded in Middleton, Connecticut, in 1785, and another in Concord, Massachusetts, in 1816.) So I had to set that aside for a while.
The third source was a paragraph from a “Loyalist writer” on the “irreconcilable difference” between Hancock and Adams, cited to “New Jersey Gazette, Jan. 14, 1776 (Moore’s Diary of the Revolution, II. 7).”
I followed Wells’s footnote to Frank Moore’s two-volume Diary of the Revolution, published in 1860, and found that both newspaper articles Wells cited appeared in Moore, not just the second.
And I found, unfortunately, that Wells had messed up both citations.
For “Caesar” offering “intelligence of great credibility,” Moore credited the Middlesex Journal, a London newspaper, not gossip in Massachusetts. No one in London would have had better knowledge of motions in the Continental Congress than the actual delegates who left us their candid letters and diaries. This report of Adams trying to expel Hancock was not just exaggerated but spurious.
I then turned to Wells’s third citation: “New Jersey Gazette, Jan. 14, 1776,” via Moore. But in this case, I found that Wells had picked up the wrong footnote at the bottom of Moore’s page. And then he misstated the date at the top of that page, which actually covered events in 1778.
TOMORROW: More gossip from behind enemy lines.




.jpeg)







.jpg)